In Dyer Need
I don’t think there has been a Newcastle United player in the last decade who has divided opinion as much as Kieron Dyer. Vital playmaking cog for some, over-rated playboy for others, but here’s a thought...
Did you know that when Kieron Dyer’s contract runs out in just under three years time he will be entitled to a testimonial after ten years at St James’s Park?
Should the 27-year-old remain on Tyneside for that long there is unlikely to be the same out-pouring of hero worship seen at Alan Shearer’s farewell bash in the summer, but Dyer, for all of his injury problems, off-field scraps and apparent ability to provoke controversy in an empty room, is absolutely vital to Glenn Roeder.
Graeme Souness made plenty of mistakes as Newcastle manager and some would say giving the notoriously injury-troubled Dyer a lucrative four-year contract was one of them. But, so good were his performances, that if you ask the Scot today what cost him his job at St James’s Park he will say Dyer’s hamstrings.
That will probably bring a vague nod from some of you and a splutter of indignation from others, but, if I may play Devil’s Advocate, I don’t think anyone can question that, with United in caught up in an unwanted and acrimonious relegation scrap, the England international’s return from injury is a rare cause for optimism in an otherwise dark campaign.
Let’s get something out in the open straight away. Yes Kieron is a friend of mine and has been since we were kids, but I am looking at this as objectively as I can.
It is not so long ago that some of Dyer’s harshest critics were calling for the midfielder to get in his expensive car, drive over the Tyne Bridge (being careful not to crash into it on the way), and never darken the doors of St James’s Park again. There is a certain irony that those same people probably now see the former Ipswich prospect as Newcastle’s potential saviour.
Having refused to play on the right wing - only after Craig Bellamy and Lee Bowyer had done exactly the same thing - under Sir Bobby Robson at the start of the 2004/5 season and then (Kieron denies this ever happened) refuse the captain’s arm band when Alan Shearer was substituted at Middlesbrough, his most vocal detractors insisted he had committed one of the worst crimes ever seen by a Newcastle player.
To be fair to them, it wasn’t his finest hour, in fact it was disgusting behaviour, but it was also the turning point in his career. With a hate campaign running again him, he was booed for weeks by his own supporters as a pantomime villain and looked doomed as a Newcastle player.
But, with Souness’ support, Dyer won back the fans with his performances on the pitch before a hamstring tear in the second leg of the Uefa Cup quarter-final against Sporting Lisbon (Newcastle were 2-0 up on aggregate at the time) begun an 18-month injury nightmare, a nightmare he is only just waking from.
There are some supporters - who will also point to the on-the-field punch up with Bowyer - who’ll argue Dyer’s injury problems are karma for being an arrogant little so and so off the pitch, but people grow up and they learn from their mistakes.
Trust me, I’ve fallen out with Kieron plenty of times in the last few years, but he is more mature and a more rounded person than ever before. He just wants to play football regularly again.
Alright, if he gets into more trouble off the pitch or has another fight with a teammate on it, he will deserve to be criticised and undoubtedly some will want him packed off to Bolton Wanderers, Blackburn Rovers or some other rehabilitation club for repeat offenders.
But, in a team short on confidence, creative spark and pace, a fit and on form Dyer could be the difference between Championship and Premiership football next season. It is a heavy burden to carry, let’s hope his hamstrings can stand up to it.
Older/Newer
« Keane Doesn't Have The Midas Touch | Roy Keane, The Ashes And Freddie Flintoff »
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: In Dyer Need.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.lukewhostalking.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/35839
5 Comments
Blog Authors
Luke Edwards - is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.
I was one of those who booed Dyer a couple of years back because he showed a lack of respect to his manager, teammates and the club be refusing to play at Boro.
But I have to agree with you Luke. Kieron's performances before his injury problems showed what a good player he can be when his mind is on it and he is fit.
I still wouldn't pay £80,000 a week for an injury-prone player - although we pay even more to another one Michael Owen - but at the moment we desperately need Dyer on the pitch. He lifted the team's performance at Manchester City. I hope his fintess probs really are behind him and this isn't another short comeback!
It just goes to show how wrong a person can be about of Kieron Dyer. I had deluded myself for so long, thinking that he was a complete waste of space, a vastly over-rated free loading, work-shy journeyman manc, .who’s personal opinion of his own talent was only outweighed by his ego. That’s certainly opened my eyes. I shall never again demean the goal shy maestro.
Ps Who wrote that very interesting but unfathomable article on 'Pro-Zone stats and the science of Championship manager', where Alan Oliver is quoted denouncing the evils of quantitative analysis?
The problem with Kieron Dyer is we've been here before. I don't think anyone questions his ability, although his goalscoring record isn't good enough for an attacking midfielder, but he simply does not play enough games a season.
Souness should never have given him a four year contract and he has been a major drain on resources.
I hope he can stay fit now. The fans have forgiven him a lot, now it's payback time.
"Did you know that when Kieron Dyer’s contract runs out in just under three years time he will be entitled to a testimonial after ten years at St James’s Park?" A Testimonial? Hold on, a second, just need a minute to regain my composure!
Ok. That's better.
"But, with Souness’ support, Dyer won back the fans with his performances " - nope, I'm sorry, I've gone again!
Brilliant Luke. And I once said you couldn't write an amusing article!
Well done, I haven't laughed so much in ages!!
Luke you might just be right. Kieron Dyer transformed us on Saturday and if he stays fit we'll be fine this season.
Having said that, Arsenal battered us, particularly in the second half and if it hadn't been for Shay Given we would have got the thumping everyone predicted.
Hopefully we can build on this with homes games against Portsmouth and Reading coming up in the league.