Grab my RSS feed | (What's this?)

About this Blog

Luke Edwards is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.

As well as football, Luke also regularly takes a wry look at the biggest sports stories from across the North-East and beyond. From cricket to rugby and basketball to boxing, some are criticised and some are praised.

Sometimes provocative, sometimes laugh-aloud funny, but always interesting Luke Who's Talking also gives you the chance to interact with Luke and have your say on all the major sporting issues.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Sponsored links


Why Does Steve Harmison Get All The Blame?

Posted by Luke on January 5, 2007 12:32 PM | 

When something bad happens, like a hugely expensive cruise ship sinking on its maiden voyage, or a carriage coming loose on a rollercoaster or Newcastle United failing to challenge at the top of the Premiership, it’s human nature to search for a scapegoat.

For the Titanic, it was the drunken captain who ploughed into an iceberg, for the carriage flying off the rollercoaster it’s the maintenance man and for Newcastle United it’s the affable Spaniard Albert Luque, so who can we blame for England’s Ashes whitewash?

I know, let’s go for the guy who is aloof in public, who doesn’t suffer fools gladly and whose laid back attitude off the pitch infuriates the single-minded try hard brigade. Yes, let’s blame Steve Harmison because that’s precisely what former England captains Nasser Hussain and Geoff Boycott want to do.

It’s all Harmy’s fault because he hasn’t taken enough wickets, his attitude stinks, his body language isn’t rigid enough, he doesn’t care about cricket and he had the cheek to say in an interview the other day that he was looking forward to going home.

How dare you Steve, how dare you want to get away from the Ashes humiliation in Australia and how dare you say that you don’t know what you will be doing when you get back.

Honestly Steve, you should want to stay in Oz and talk to crowing Aussies everyday for the next three months and when you get home, you should head straight to the Riverside for 12 hours of net practice seven days a week, you fiend, because that’s what Nasser and Geoff would have done.

This of course is the same Nasser Hussain who never played in a victorious Ashes series and whose side only narrowly escaped from a series whitewash four years ago with a fortunate victory in Sydney. This is the same Nasser who clung on to the captaincy for far too long because of the kudos it gave him when everyone could see England needed a change in leadership.

This is the same Nasser Hussain who constantly complained about ex-pros criticising the England team and him and the same Nasser Hussain who retired as soon as he had got one last international century so he could have the last word on his critics.

As for Boycott, he is arguably one of the most selfish individuals to have played a team sport for England, a batsman who was always more interested in how many runs he scored than whether the team won and who made a habit of running partners out by calling risky singles to add to his total.

So thanks guys, let’s blame Harmison for everything that has gone wrong - and there has been plenty - Down Under.

No, the reason we lost the Ashes goes like this;

Harmison was under-prepared having played virtually no four day cricket in three months. As a rhythm bowler, he only started to find it when the series was already lost.
Why did he not play in Durham’s final Championship match of the season when fit? Why was he playing ill-suited one day cricket when he could have been playing club cricket in Australia or New Zealand to find his rhythm?

England did not spend enough time in Australia playing warm up games before the start of the series because they were playing in the stupid ICC Trophy.

Ashley Giles played instead of Monty Panesar in the first two tests, hardly took a wicket, didn’t score any runs and dropped Ricky Ponting. A bit like playing Stuart McGill instead of Shane Warne.

England lost three key players from the triumphant 2005 Series before a ball had been bowled. Captain Michael Vaughan, opening batsman Michael Trescothick and fast bowler Simon Jones. Take Ponting, Justin Langer and Brett Lee away from Australia and how would they have done?

Freddie Flintoff, England insipration in 2005, was not fully fit and struggled to cope with the extra burden of being captain as well as crucial all-rounder.

Australia were simply awesome as their old brigade, still smarting from the Ashes defeat 18 months ago, went out in style.
They, will however, have to completely rebuild their side following the retirement of Damien Martyn, Warne, Glenn McGrath, Langer and probably Matthew Hayden and Adam Glichrist as well.

England, in contrast, have a young team which will almost certainly still be together in two and a half years time. We’ll get them back, but in the meantime, let’s blame Harmison because that’s really constructive isn’t it?

TrackBack

TrackBack<$MTEntryTrackbackLink$>>

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference <$MTEntryTitle$>:

">

» <$MTPingTitle$> from <$MTPingBlogName$>
<$MTPingExcerpt$> [Read More]

Tracked on <$MTPingDate$>

Comments (4)

Glenn McGrath wrote...

Steve Harmison's opening ball was so wide it was taken at second slip. It set the tone for the whole series.

The only danger to Australia from his bowling was that they'd be laughing so hard they wouldn't be able concentrate.

Posted by: Glenn McGrath  | January 7, 2007 11:38 AM

Desree wrote...

As a geordie in Australia to be honest I was embarrassed by Harmison's lack of fight and attitude. He deserves his barracking and I've heard Hussein slate all the England players - I'm sure they didn't pick Harmison out because he's from the North East but because he was rubbish.

Posted by: Desree  | January 9, 2007 6:11 AM

Mike Fraser wrote...

As another geordie living in Australia, and having watched every test I would have to agree with Luke's comments. Harmison was underdone due to the lack of bowling opportunity but improved significantly from the 3rd test on up until the last day in Sydney where Langer reckoned he had bowled really well (as well as being well bruised). I only wish Harmy had played last night in the 20:20 instead of Anderson or Lewis!
I had no problem with his attitude, he nearly top scored in our last innings at the SCG when he was left stranded by the tail as he was going for his maiden test century

Posted by: Mike Fraser  | January 9, 2007 10:22 PM

mum wrote...

Having safely returned from our Australian tour and survived the outspoken comments of various Australian friends - although their overall attitude was one of great disappointment and wanting England to make a fight of it, I wanted to lend support to the Harmison cause. He was ill prepared for the series and with match practice got better and better as well as sticking in there with his batting, we certainly missed him in the 20-20.
It wasn't Harmy who was to blame but the whole England squad - watching them come out on to the field was embarassing, their body language spoke volumes. Whereas the Australians literally bounded onto the field, were keen to get on with it and their fielding was quite superb. England sloped on, did a sort of pathetic huddle and then performed as if they wished they were somewhere else.
There were a few exceptions - Panesar, Hoggard, Pietersen up to a point, tho' I always feel he is far too self interested. There was little support for each other and Flintoff looked a haunted man.
As for Hussein the sooner he is got rid off the better - he is such a grim man.
Did anyone stop to think what affect the over celebration of winning last time and especially the awarding of MBEs to one and all had on the Aussies? They were a really superb team.

Posted by: mum  | January 10, 2007 2:47 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)