Nobody Got Hurt
Is it just me or rather than plunge the game into disrepute and blacken the name of English football, the scuffle between Arsenal and Chelsea players in the Carling Cup Final actually provided a nice sprinkle of spice to a thoroughly enjoyable game?
So a few shoves and pushes were exchanged and Wayne Bridge was floored by the worst punch seen since Michael Sprout dropped Audley Harrison, but come on, was it really that bad?
Listening to Radio Five Live on the way back from Newcastle’s dreadful defeat at Wigan on Sunday I heard all the usual moralising from pundits who labelled the squabble a disgusting, terrible act which ruined the game and cast a black cloud over both clubs.
Both teams should be ashamed of themselves and the FA should punish them all by hitting them across the knuckle with a ruler or fine them £2,000 because that’s what they normally do to “punish� big club offenders who can pay with the loose change in their suit trousers.
What the sanctimonious experts seemed to have misunderstood, though, is that football fans - you know, the people who finance the game and their wages - tend to enjoy this sort of thing. A good scrap always adds to the excitement and proves the player’s care. In that respect and as much as it pains me to say it, I agree with Frank Lampard.
I know it is not a violent game, but in contact sports emotions are always likely to spill over every now and again and as long as there isn’t anything that might be considered an assault in a court of law I don’t see what the problem is.
If something like that happened on a rugby field - and it regularly does - nobody would bat an eyelid, in fact, they’d say it was all part of the game and chortle into their beer.
You certainly wouldn’t have to put up with people crying that the little kiddies up and down the country will be imitating their heroes and ruining the game at grassroots level.
That was done a long time ago through a lack of decent coaching, the implementation of the Academy system, the rise in popularity of computer games and the sale of school sports fields.
These sort of scene have been seen countless times before and they will be seen countless times again. It is sport, it is a battle and sometimes it needs an extra edge to make it the drama we all crave.
Older/Newer
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Nobody Got Hurt.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.lukewhostalking.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/35579




when will they get Alan Green off the airwaves? Even Mark "he's got a face like a angel" Lawrenson felt constantly obliged to point out that most of Alan's opinions on refereeing decisions and players behaviour were hopelessly wrong.
When you listen to him commentate you are always under the impression it's the worst game of football ever seen or that all the players are morally bankrupt and incompetent, or both. I have to listen to negative idiots whinging and moaning all around me at every home game - I really don't need to hear it from a (well) paid radio commentator as well. Oh, and he's got a face for radio too! Surprise, surprise.
Salient point Luke, if Ice hockey punch ups aren’t orchestrated then how is it that no one has ever been charged unlike that nasty little Lee Bowyer? I mean these guys are vicious with sticks and pointy blades n stuff, and as for wrestling and boxing, well these dudes just hit each other and get away with it whilst the law turns an all too familiar blind eye, its high time something was done!
I see your good friend Dyer is out again, when is the medical world going to find that cure for hypochondria?
p.s. excellent word 'chortle'
Couldn't agree more with you Dan, Alan Green is a relic, an antagonistic, self-opinionated, self-important, pompus prat who knows very little about football. How on earth he works for the BBC I don't know, although he probably went to the right school or something