Grab my RSS feed | (What's this?)

About this Blog

Luke Edwards is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.

As well as football, Luke also regularly takes a wry look at the biggest sports stories from across the North-East and beyond. From cricket to rugby and basketball to boxing, some are criticised and some are praised.

Sometimes provocative, sometimes laugh-aloud funny, but always interesting Luke Who's Talking also gives you the chance to interact with Luke and have your say on all the major sporting issues.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Sponsored links


A Crucial Appointment In More Ways Than One

Posted by Luke on May 15, 2007 7:49 PM | 

So "Sam the Man" is finally here and he is excited about the prospect of unlocking Newcastle's potential to compete with the best in the Premiership.

He’s not the only one, of course, because similar words and phrases have tumbled out of the mouths of everyone who has sat in the manager’s chair for the first time since Joe Harvey guided the club to that Fairs Cup success everyone keeps harking on about in 1969.

We know Newcastle have the potential to compete with the biggest clubs in the country, the problem is, with the odd exception of the Kevin Keegan and Sir Bobby Robson years, they have failed miserably to do that.

Big name managers have tried and failed, big name players have come and gone but, like Old Mother Hubbard, the trophy cupboard - erm, it’s probably a dusty cabinet anyway - is bare.

Do I think Sam Allardyce will be different? I certainly hope so.

On the face of things, he has the character, the temperament and the know-how to inspire the players he has inherited. He is determined to change things behind the scenes as well as on the pitch and he wants - in words that echoed Roy Keane’s when he took over at Sunderland - to change the culture at the football club.

Impressive sentiments and persuasive arguments, but only time will tell whether he will succeed where so many others have failed. He sported a wide smile at his unveiling press conference, let’s just hope he is still smiling in 18 months time.

Allardyce is not the most popular of appointments, but I question whether there was really any other alternative. All right, so I had my one-man campaign for Sven-Goran Eriksson, but Ottmar Hitzfeld? Not a chance, Gerard Houllier? Possibly, but would he really be any better?

I guess, all supporters can do now is get behind the team or don’t bother renewing your season tickets. Blind loyalty I know - look try telling yourself that is worth the time and effort to watch Leyton Orient - but isn’t that always the case with your football club? Isn’t that what makes Newcastle unique, the sheer number of you who are blinded by your loyalty?

Wow, I sound like a season ticket salesman for Freddie Shepherd don’t I? I don’t mean to, I’m just saying..... Look I don’t know what I’m saying, but I bet you understand what I’m trying to get across....

As for Freddie, this is his sixth managerial appointment and there is a huge amount of pressure on it being a successful one. He has got two wrong since Robson in Graeme Souness and Glenn Roeder and if he is to avoid a widening of the protests against him that we saw this season, Allardyce needs to succeed.

Lest we forget, when the fans protested after the defeat by Blackburn earlier this month, there were just as many chants for his head as there were for Roeder’s.

Anyway, it should make for an interesting summer at least.

I’ve not had the chance to comment about Obafemi Martins and Charles N’Zogbia’s behaviour at Watford have I. From what I’ve heard, neither can be defended.

Just because Oba has scored 17 goals this season, that does not excuse withdrawing yourself from the squad because you don’t want to be a substitute does it? Kieron Dyer did something similar when he didn’t want to play on the right wing and look what happened to him.

I’ve questioned Oba’s performances since the home game against Alkmaar in February and, again, from what I’ve heard from inside the dressing room, his commitment and attitude have been questioned by his teammates for some time.

As for Charlie, he was a really nice kid with lots of potential who sulked when Damien Duff was signed. He wasn’t handled that well by Roeder, but his head is up his - I’ll leave that last bit to your imagination, there might be children reading.

He either withdraws it, starts concentrating on football again, or, as much as it pains me to say it, he packs his bag and leaves. One thing is certain, I bet he wouldn’t behave like he has if he was at Arsenal!

TrackBack

TrackBack<$MTEntryTrackbackLink$>>

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference <$MTEntryTitle$>:

">

» <$MTPingTitle$> from <$MTPingBlogName$>
<$MTPingExcerpt$> [Read More]

Tracked on <$MTPingDate$>

Comments (11)

medan wrote...

I have to disagree with you about Oba, the guy was hammered by the media including yourself from day one, he scores critical goals playing in an average team that has not attacking service and he still gets critized for showing effort and commitement my goodness how the hell do you score 17 goals sitting on your ass and not being committed if Oba has such skills he is worth 30 million pounds. In terms of what happened the last game why the hell would a subsitute coach tell 2 talented players to start as subsitutes in a last game of a season, most good coaches would have started with the original starting 11 and make changes in the second half, there is no question in my mind the decsion was based on bais. Nick Butt is a hypocrit he nows dam well that Oba has no problem sitting on the bench.Oba did it in newcastle and Inter, I did not see him critize Oba when he was scoring the goals that kept the team away from relegation, he was a lone striker carrying the attack to other teams with very ineffective midfield for most of the year. Yes no player is above the rules of the club but I have to tell you Oba has been used as escapegoat for this team's failure, while Dirk Kuyt and Dimitri Bebatraov are heros playing in teams that has better midfiled and partenered by at least 2 proper stikers(12-15 goals).


I hope Sam looks at this nonsense and does something about it.

Note From Luke
To say I hammered Oba from day one is, to coin a phrase used by one my colleagues, "well wide of the mark" I constantly stuck up for him at the start when he wasn't scoring goals and I've praised him to the hilt when it has been due.
I just don't think he has looked as interested in the final quarter of the season, although he has not been the only one, and his performances have dipped alarmingly. My main point was, however, that much of the criticism is coming from teammates. Not just Nicky Butt on the record, but plenty off it as well.
I hope this is a wake up call to him and he comes beack next season with renewed focus

Posted by: medan  | May 15, 2007 10:56 PM

Richard wrote...

Good points on both Charles and Oba. i think a lot of fans have become - as you'd say - blinded by Oba's goals earlier in the season. He has been poor recently and it seems there are wider problems behind the scenes.

As for Charles, I really thought he was going to be a star last season, but he's done nothing this year. I've also seen him out on the town a few times and he certainly thinks he is a superstar without doing anything to suggest that on the pitch this season.

I don't want to lose him, I just want Sam to sort it out

Posted by: Richard  | May 16, 2007 9:34 AM

Dan wrote...

"I’ve not had the chance to comment about Obafemi Martins and Charles N’Zogbia’s behaviour at Watford have I."

Please set an example for your readers and learn to punctuate, chum. There's a comma, apostrophe and question mark missing from that sentence for a start. All the best.

Note From Luke
Sorry Dan, I'm sometimes a little too quick when I write my blog and don't check things. It's a bit like turning on a tap in my brain, which then flows through my fingertips. New Media, new possibilities, bad punctuation!

Posted by: Dan  | May 16, 2007 10:27 AM

Graham wrote...

Obviously Nicky Butt's comments are not what the supporters of any club want to hear. Most fans would give anything to wear that shirt, and expect the same from those lucky enough to be able to do so. However, I think people need to be cautious about assuming he's referring to Martins and NZogbia, who's (unacceptable) tantrums were as a result of not getting picked to start last Sunday. Butt's comment was that some players don't want to play for the club, and I can think of a few who have managed to do just that this season - sometimes with the most mystifying "injuries".

Posted by: Graham  | May 16, 2007 1:58 PM

med wrote...

OK Luke I have to admit you were not as harsh on Martin as the others. But I still believe a person does not suddenly become disinterested or noncommited after playing his heart out most of the season. The whole team was weak in the second half of the season and people need to understand how tough it is on a young player to come into a team from playing with a team like Inter into Newcastle and find the mess that exists in this team.

Wow, I can say with high probability that non of the imports this year including Dirk Kuyt and Dimitri Bebatraov would have done better playing in this team.

Posted by: med  | May 16, 2007 6:14 PM

michael wrote...

WORD TO MEDAN!...its Dimitar Berbatov not Dimitri

Note From Luke
Yeah Medan!

Posted by: michael  | May 17, 2007 11:56 AM

javed shaikh wrote...

hey luke,
Whatever has happened at viscerage park should be forgiven and has sam said everyone begins with a clean sheet now . we should not be too harsh with both charles and oba coz both are fantastic players and should be persisted with . it wud be difficult to replace them especially oba who has been fantastic for most part of the season and dont forget he has been playing alone as a lone striker since the intertoto cup and i think we should give him the benifit of doubt since we werent doing that good after az alkaimer match the confidence level of the team as a whole started drooping . I for one seriously doubt the man management skills of glen roeder who after the uefa cup debacle wasnt able to lift the team and in this regard i feel big sam will play a big part . i have all my hopes on big sam . i really wanna see newcastle lifting a cup next season BEST OF LUCK BIG SAM

Javed Shaikh

Indian Geordie

Posted by: javed shaikh  | May 17, 2007 12:15 PM

Paul Pringle wrote...

Nicky Butt is the most professional player we've got. If he speaks out on the record then it is for a good reason. If spoilt little upstarts like the Zog want to spit their dummy out, let them - he wouldn't get a game at Arsenal anyway.

However, I can see how it looks to him - billed as a player - with Milner - we would build a team around, to languishing on the subs bench in favour of Mr Duff must have made the young frenchie wonder.

And here's a prediction - Duff will be starting on the left for Sunderland next season.

Lay off Oba, jury's still out on Zog

Pringy

Posted by: Paul Pringle  | May 17, 2007 3:22 PM

desree wrote...

Hey Luke

Let's remember we are talking about a bunch of kids here. Regardless of how much money they are paid, both are away from their families and under great pressure.

From what I can see it's Newcastle United that acts unprofessionally so is it any surprise this filters through to the players?

Who could blame Oba for going to Chelsea or Owen for wanting to leave. Both these guys have played for highly successful clubs with a recent tradition for winning major trophies. They are winners and winners only want the best. The fans and Stadium can only compensate for so much.

Hopefully big Sam will sort out the mess and get Newcastle the team they deserve. By the way, I live in Sydney and a mate of mine has been told that Viduka will be joining the toon. Have you guys heard anything your end?

Note From Luke
All I know is that Newcastle are trying to sign him for a fourth time. You would have thought they'd have taken no for an answer by now!

Posted by: desree  | May 17, 2007 10:32 PM

Frank - NUFC Fan from Angola wrote...

At least the 20.000 fans that welcomed Owen to SJP can blame him for leaving,
I will anyway,
meantime I calculated that he might be the best paid player ever or at least the most costly!?
If he goes we loose 8million Pound on top his wages of 110.000pound per week totals 19,44 million for 14 games, considering he played the full 90 minutes each game means he will have costed us over 15000pound per minute,

thank you Graeme Souness, we will hold the record for the most costly players, can somebody make this same account for Luque considering we get rid of him for naught?

back to MO, he should be
thanking NUFC (on his knees) for saving his career by playing and scoring goals till the end of his contract,

I hope big Sam gets the overpaid kids under control, and some of them should not be awarded even the chance of wearing our colours ever again,

out of consideration for the 52000fans, those that have to work hard every week to buy a ticket, to see what?!

it is their loyalty to the club that makes NUFC a great club,
can we also expect some loyalty of the players?

I am confident that SAM will swing it around and prevent us from ending up in League 1 in 2 to 3 years time, playing Leeds and Nothingham Forest,
2 other big clubs that went down because of bad management and overspending,
Sam knows how to get results working with small budgets - we will need that!




Posted by: Frank - NUFC Fan from Angola  | May 19, 2007 7:33 PM

trev wrote...

Let Martins go. 17 goals or not, he is NOT a good centre forward. Main assets, speed, strength and a powerful shot. Is that enough in the modern game? No it is not. He is hopeless at holding up the ball. When receiving it with his back to the goal, he always attempts to turn with it rather than laying it off. He then invariably loses the ball when the defender hooks around him and boots it off his toes. His passing is p... poor also. Not least, his temperament and commitment are obviously in doubt .

I believe Owen is likely to leave because he has no regional loyalty and will want to be sure to win something - having had two managers who promised that NUFC's days of glory were just around the corner and is now faced with a third, probably telling him the same.

That said, his outrageous wages could be the deciding factor in any proposed move as most of the top clubs are unlikely to want to pay this Kings ransom for a player who is injury prone.

Let's forget about the "stars" and get a bunch of hard working, loyal and committed players who are going to put the effort in every week.

Note to Medan: You must have been watching another Martins to me and many others. I'll bet you've got a replica shirt with Martins on the back!

Note From Luke
Now now children!

Posted by: trev  | May 22, 2007 2:41 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)