Grab my RSS feed | (What's this?)

About this Blog

Luke Edwards is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.

As well as football, Luke also regularly takes a wry look at the biggest sports stories from across the North-East and beyond. From cricket to rugby and basketball to boxing, some are criticised and some are praised.

Sometimes provocative, sometimes laugh-aloud funny, but always interesting Luke Who's Talking also gives you the chance to interact with Luke and have your say on all the major sporting issues.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Sponsored links


What A Refreshing Change

Posted by Luke on December 6, 2007 6:49 PM | 

There wasn't a can of Woodpecker in sight - not unless Mike Ashley had some spares stuffed up his cashmere coat - but what a refreshing change for Newcastle United against Arsenal.

Whether you nodded your head in agreement or turned a funny shade of crimson when you read them, Joey Barton's criticism of the atmosphere at St James's Park appears to have had the desired effect.

It's all well and good going on about how passionate and loyal you are as supporters - and I'm not saying you're not before anyone thinks about sending anthrax to me in the post - but you also have to prove it every now and again.

he thing that struck me on Wednesday night was you could see Arsenal's players were visibly shaken by the experience. They may escaped with their unbeaten record intact, but they were shaken on the pitch by the level of determination they faced and they were shaken by the hostility they were greeted with from the stands. That is what St James's Park used to be like every week! Teams used to hate coming up here.

Maybe it was just the performance which galvanised those in the stands into voice, the fact they were actually given something to get excited about on the pitch. But I can't help but feel, even before kick-off, that there was a different mood in the ground, the players responded to it and, when their efforts inspired the crowd into even louder support, they upped their level of performance another notch.

When Newcastle scored their thoroughly deserved equaliser midway through the second half, I feared Arsenal would simply raise their game and score another one. The most impressive thing was, Newcastle didn't let them and, while Sam Allardyce may have come out with some rather strange things after games this season - prattling on about international breaks at Derby County for example - I don't think anyone disagreed with him when he said Newcastle were the team who looked like winning it in the second half.

So well done Sam, well done the players and well done you lot. I was impressed with everything I saw and heard on Wednesday night and, let me tell you, it's been a mighty long time since that happened! So everyone pat yourself on the back and feel content in the knowledge that it was a job well done.

However - there is always a however with me isn't there - need I point out that the improvements made against the league leaders will count for didley squat if there is not the same level of performance against Birmingham City on Saturday.

This has to be the start of something, not just an oasis in a desert of garbage. With games against the Brummies, Fulham, Derby and Wigan next on the agenda, I hope that, when you all open your Christmas stockings, this nasty little spell is nothing more than a bad memory!

Remember, Newcastle drew at Arsenal last season under Glenn Roeder and they beat the Gunners at home under Graeme Souness. The difference on Wednesday, though, was that Newcastle were, for long periods the better side, so that is really encouraging. Nothing but the same, though, will be tolerated at the weekend!

TrackBack

TrackBack<$MTEntryTrackbackLink$>>

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference <$MTEntryTitle$>:

">

» <$MTPingTitle$> from <$MTPingBlogName$>
<$MTPingExcerpt$> [Read More]

Tracked on <$MTPingDate$>

Comments (11)

Phil wrote...

You know Luke, I reckon that refreshing change that you refer to, includes the "coming of age" of Steven Taylor. He scored a goal that was so important for the whole of Geordieland, and, but for a post, would have had two. Who knows, his goal might have changed the course of a season. I reckon Nicky Butt owes him a pint or two for that desperate stop on Adebayor at the end of the match (Butt had an excellent game, but made a weak back pass which was intercepted). If young "Stevie" keeps it up, I'm sure Sam Alladyce and co. will revisit the young fella's contract issue in good time. Taylor certainly showed last night the qualities of a leader and (as Bob Moncur wisely said) a possible future captain. Taylor's commitment and absolute genuine joy for his beloved Geordieland after scoring his most important goal, only added to the euphoria. He may not yet be the finished article, but his heart is in the right place, and he's learning fast. There will be ups and downs this season, but I can't wait to see more of the United Club spirit we saw on Wednesday!

Note From Luke
Taylor wasn't the only player to stand out for me on the night. Having criticised him in the past, I thought Alan Smith was fantastic and James Milner, particularly in the second half, was brilliant. Taylor could be a fantastic defender, but he always seems to be flying by the seat of his pants, in contrast to someone like Jonathan Woodgate, who never seems to be flustered. I hope Tayls makes it, because he's a smashing lad, but it's probably worth pointing out - as I'm sure Sam will - that he was supposed to be marking Adebayor when he opened the scoring after four mins. Adebayor was his man, not Rozehnal's!

Posted by: Phil  | December 7, 2007 1:38 AM

Phil wrote...

You know Luke, I reckon that refreshing change that you refer to, includes the "coming of age" of Steven Taylor. He scored a goal that was so important for the whole of Geordieland, and, but for a post, would have had two. Who knows, his goal might have changed the course of a season. I reckon Nicky Butt owes him a pint or two for that desperate stop on Abadyor at the end of the match (Butt had an excellent game, but made a weak back pass which was intercepted). If young "Stevie" keeps it up, I'm sure Sam Alladyce and co. will revisit the young fella's contract issue in good time. Taylor certainly showed last night the qualities of a leader and (as Bob Moncur wisely said) a possible future captain. Taylor's commitment and absolute genuine joy for his beloved Geordieland after scoring his most important goal, only added to the euphoria. He may not yet be the finished article, but his heart is in the right place, and he's learning fast. There will be ups and downs this season, but I can't wait to see more of the United Club spirit we saw on Wednesday!

Note From Luke
Couldn't agree with you more Phil

Posted by: Phil  | December 7, 2007 1:39 AM

James 09 wrote...

Hugely improved performance and a fantastic atmosphere at SJP. Due credit to the players and staff, and every single Newcastle United supporter who bellowed their lungs out throughout the match.

That level of commitment from players should be there week in week out though, and it has been decidedly absent in too many matches this season. Despite all the criticism in the media we received, our response at the Liverpool match was fully justified, if not necessary, and may now have taught any staff and player who were not already aware, just what Newcastle United is all about.

However, last night’s performance and valuable point will count for very little if we don’t take the vital step in beating Brum and Derby at SJP. Losing to Derby, even though very early in our season, has become a national embarrassment. We MUST start consistently beating teams like Brum, Derby, and Wigan – home AND away.

The improved performances at Blackburn and now against Arsenal give absolutely no weight to Zog (or anyone else) being persistently played out of position. Surely against at least Brum and Derby, Allardyce can give Enrique (who he spent a big portion of his transfer budget on) more Premiership experience and allow the potentially electric Zog to play where he should. That would also allow Milner to play in his natural (and of course best) position. And as Wednesday again proved, if Smith is on the field at all, he should be upfront - not in midfield. Let’s hope this occurs at the weekend.

Finally, performances like Wednesday CAN significantly alter the trajectory of a season, BUT far from always do. 2 points from 18 remains miserable form, and let’s embrace caution and see how we go in these next run of games. We absolutely should not get carried away like a significant number (some staff, players, media, and supporters) did after the Tottenham win. If we take seven plus points from our next 12, then we can look to the New Year with some degree of optimism.

Posted by: James 09  | December 7, 2007 3:59 AM

Michael wrote...

Wednesday's committment and work rate could not be faulted and if we show the same we will win a lot more than we lose. However, I would still like to see more awareness and penetration that we will need against lesser teams that come to SJP to defend. For that reason I can't wait for Michael Owen to join Alan Smith up front. I don't understand why Martins is so popular! As my mate says 'he has all the awareness of a dead swan'. Alan smith must have won 90% of the headers he contested and Martins got on the end of precisely none. Why didn't he square it to an unmarked Geremi in the first half rather than take on two defenders, how many times did the ball end up at the back post and Martins didn't gamble that it would? He consistently choses the wrong option but occasionally smacks one in and all is forgiven. If Michael Owen had been playing on Wednesday we would have won! He is the best finisher playing in the Premier League and some of you want him sold. It beggars belief!

Posted by: Michael  | December 7, 2007 9:18 AM

Mal wrote...

I'm sure sam will also point out to taylor that zog has been unfairly blamed for the goal. Taylor should have cleared it first rather than put zog under pressure. But I agree with the overall sentiments about taylor - he is still only young and can become a newcastle great with good guidance and experience. Great performance by the team and supporters on wednesday (and wasn't the referee good?)and hopefully they will take this into the birmingham game on saturday. We've been here before only to be let down.

Posted by: Mal  | December 7, 2007 9:38 AM

Paul Patterson wrote...

Now where would we get anthrax from?

Oh and Strongbow?? I think if you check it was:- 'WOODPECKER- WHAT A REFRESHING CHANGE'

Back in our pomp (Circa 1996) the atmosphere was electric, something which hasn’t been replicated with the introduction of the new improvements to the ground- the noise simply escapes through the roof, where as when 36,000 used to pact St James’ the nooks and crannies used to bounce the noise back down towards the pitch.

Against Arsenal there was a noticeable difference partly smashing this theory to pieces, so what was the difference you ask? Well everybody wanted that result and performance against Arsenal- I mean REALLY WANTED it and that was evident from kick off.

Against Birmingham tomorrow I hope for more of the same, whilst fans must play their part, so do the players at management- Ie- Go for it again, Birmingham are not the best side, in fact the best description of them can be ‘workman-like’ and nothing more. I’ll be watching Kapo as he looks a good player, but that apart I wouldn’t be frightened of them too much.

Raise The Roof!!!

Paul.

Note From Luke
You're right, it was woodpecker! Must change it straight away

Posted by: Paul Patterson  | December 7, 2007 10:31 AM

Lee wrote...

Didn't wednesday night just confirm some of the mistakes Big Sam has made over the last few weeks? For the first time in weeks he sent out a pretty much unchanged side in the same formation that played well at Blackburn. Prior to that he messed around with the team every week to the point that Shay Given must have wondered when it was his turn on the wing. My feeling is that Allardyce is caught up in this vision of himself as a tactical genius so he concentrates too much on second-guessing the opposition. Good teams get their own house in order and leave the opposition to do the worrying. There's preparing your own team and then there's accommodating the opposition. Plus it makes a huge difference when players get to play in their propoer positions. Smith has bee god-awful all season in the middle and on the wing but he was excellent as the lone frontman. It may be controversial to say so but do our problems stem from Michael Owen's inability to be anything other than a goalpoacher? He can't play in a 4-3-3 as he isn't a willing runner on the wings like Martins and he isn't strong enough to be a target man. I'm starting to think that, good as he is, Owen is a luxury player in the modern game. There must be something other than injury that stopped top teams from bidding for him in both 2005 and 2007.

Note From Luke
I certainly don't think Owen can be certain to walk straight back into the side when he is fit, although Allardyce's job will be made easier by the fact Martins will be heading off to play in African Nations Cup in January.

Posted by: Lee  | December 7, 2007 12:13 PM

Ben wrote...

I wonder if we will suddently feel like the good times are back when SAFC beat Chelsea at the weekend? Probably not as we can keep out feet on the ground... and yes I am dillusional to think SAFC will beat Chelsea, but it seems to me that thats the way people are these days, so when in Rome... and anyway it was only a draw!

cheers
Ben

ps - well done on a good performance to NUFC, not trying to take anything away from that

Posted by: Ben  | December 7, 2007 12:27 PM

Phil wrote...

Couldn't agree more, Luke, with your praise of Alan Smith and Jamie Milner. Smith has looked average in midfield, but his non-stop running up front was a great boost to the whole team, and something Newcastle has never had up front, for a long time. Milner gave Arsenal's defence a lot of anxiety, as he is looking much more tricky on the ball. Could it be that players are finding their niches now? Soon, hopefully, we'll have a balanced formation, and a successful player in every position.

Posted by: Phil  | December 7, 2007 4:27 PM

James 09 wrote...

Hugely improved performance and a fantastic atmosphere at SJP. Due credit to the players and staff, and every single Newcastle United supporter who bellowed their lungs out throughout the match.

That level of commitment from players should be there week in week out though, and it has been decidedly absent in too many matches this season. Despite all the criticism in the media we received, our response at the Liverpool match was fully justified, if not necessary, and may have taught any staff and players who were not already aware, just what Newcastle United is all about.

However, last night’s performance and valuable point will count for very little if we don’t take the vital step in beating Brum and Derby at SJP. Losing to Derby, even though very early in our season, has become a national embarrassment. We MUST start consistently beating teams like Brum, Derby, and Wigan – home and away.

The improved performances at Blackburn and now against Arsenal give absolutely no weight to Zog being persistently played out of position. Surely against Brum and Derby, Allardyce can give Enrique (who he spent a big portion of his transfer budget on) more Premiership experience and allow the potentially electric Zog to play where he should. That would also allow Milner to play in his natural (and of course best) position. And as Wednesday again proved, if Smith is on the field at all, he should be upfront - not in midfield. Let’s hope this occurs at the weekend.

Performances like Wednesday CAN significantly alter the trajectory of a season, BUT far from always do. 2 points from 18 remains miserable form, and let’s embrace caution and see how we go in these next run of games. We absolutely should not get carried away like a significant number did after the Tottenham win. If we take 7 plus points from our next 12, we can begin to look to the New Year with some degree of optimism.

Posted by: James 09  | December 8, 2007 7:42 AM

Anonymous wrote...

Rather strange comments from Stuart Rayner in todays Journal -Luke I think you may need to have a word with your co-hort-

'Portsmouth’s 3-1 victory over the Magpies was even more comprehensive than the scoreline suggested'

How true this comment is when Portsmouth actually won 4-1.

Tsk, Tsk.

Paul.

Note From Luke
It's my first day back in the office after (another) short break and that was the first thing that hit me this morning. Stuart will be subjected to all sorts of vile punishments for this!

Posted by: Anonymous  | December 12, 2007 10:48 AM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)