Grab my RSS feed | (What's this?)

About this Blog

Luke Edwards is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.

As well as football, Luke also regularly takes a wry look at the biggest sports stories from across the North-East and beyond. From cricket to rugby and basketball to boxing, some are criticised and some are praised.

Sometimes provocative, sometimes laugh-aloud funny, but always interesting Luke Who's Talking also gives you the chance to interact with Luke and have your say on all the major sporting issues.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Sponsored links


It's Just Not Cricket

Posted by Luke on April 28, 2008 12:47 PM | 

There are just some things in life which don’t go together. Oil and water, chocolate and fireguards, Kevin Keegan and pessimism, Brits and abroad, Amy Winehouse and rehab. For me, though, you can add something else to that list. Americans and English sports.

We have all watched in amused bewilderment as Liverpool’s proud traditions as a football club have been soured by the bickering and balderdash of their American owners. And we have scratched our heads as Manchester United become a global franchise for some ginger bearded bloke from Tampa who looks like he wears socks with his sandals. What’s his name again? Glazer, that’s it.

But, not content with getting their chubby, money-grabbing little hands on football - you might have got David Beckham to call it soccer but I will never submit - the yanks want to move into cricket as well.

The cheek of it. I mean, at least they play a bit of football on the other side of the Atlantic. As far as I’m aware, there isn’t a single cricket pitch in America because they’re too busy playing rounders - sorry baseball - all summer. So why on earth would they be interested in cricket?

Well, as ever, money is the main one and with the explosion of Twenty20 cricket in India, it looks as though there is plenty of money to be made from this new form of the game.

Isn’t it typical, by the way, that the English, having invented Twenty20 cricket, have found out that other countries are better at it than us! Didn’t much the same thing happen with football and rugby and I don’t think we’ve been the best team in the world in any form of cricket since the 19th century so why should we think we’ll be any better at the Twenty20 stuff?

Well, for those of you who don't know, having invented this new form of the game, we have allowed the Indians to create a new league which offers huge amounts of money to bring in the best players from all over the world while we sit around twiddling our thumbs and witter on about tradition.

Actually, that’s not entirely fair. With the prospect of the Indian Premier League stealing all our best players at the start of our summer, the English Cricket Board has responded by talking to a Texan billionaire, Allen Stanford, about the possibility of establishing a similar league over here.

Stanford, you see, has become interested in cricket because he lives in the Caribbean, but that doesn’t mean he knows much about it. Hence why he can come out with ludicrous statements like Twenty20 cricket will eventually be bigger than football.

Hmm, let me see Allen. A game played by a handful of countries, mainly former British colonies, against a game that is played in every country on the planet. Yeah, like that’s ever going to happen.

But the madness does not end there, oh no, it’s just getting started. In other efforts to respond to the threat of the IPL there is talk of abandoning the traditional county system in favour of regional franchises.

Oh you’ll love this. This means Durham will be merged with Lancashire and Yorkshire - because there is absolutely no rivalry there, nope forget history, forget the War of the Roses, forget everything - while Surrey, Essex and Middlesex will become one London team. Nottinghamshire, Leicestershire and Derbyshire would become an East Midlands team and so on.

There are 120 miles between Lancashire and Durham so we’re not exactly neighbours are we. And can you imagine a Yorkshireman leaping around with a four sign above his head as he watches the cheerleaders celebrate another boundary for that well known Lancastrian Andrew Flintoff.

Unbelievable. If this is the best American innovation can offer, I think I’d rather stick to watching county cricket being played without any of the best players in front of rows and rows of empty seats up and down the country.

In truth, something will be done to respond to the threat of the IPL because, while we are all too willing not to be the best on the pitch at something, we do pride ourselves in being the best at making money out of it. Just look at football.

It will represent a monumental change in how cricket is played - as well as how much money the best players can earn - and so on. But while we may need American money to help us offer the wages to compete with the IPL, that is all we need. If I see a single stars and stripes flag anywhere near a cricket ground I’ll, I’ll, I’ll stamp my foot and be really annoyed.

Comments (8)

Paul Patterson wrote...

Luke- Americans in English sport?- Run fast and run far, the demise of the game (various sports that is) is nigh if these lard arse’s and legal junkies get their grubby mitts on anything that actually stops still for more than ten seconds.

My last post was very long so I will be brief- Picture the scene- Steven Taylor knocks a stray long ball out into the St James’ Park press box and everyone takes stock, makes a substitution and takes on lucozade.

Back at home, Sky customers are watching Budweiser toads burp the advert and mere mortals are being advised that Chicken Tonight is the way to go to feed the family for supper.

Referee blows for half time and those people sitting in the bar are watching Coca Cola plug their latest drink ‘Coca Cola with Rum and Milk’ (Seriously try it!!) and then once returning to their seat ‘Macdonalds’ are gently cramming their nutritious (Yeah right) ‘Happy Meals’ down impressionable young kids ears whilst Steven Taylor and co are inside getting blocked of Kevin for a lacklustre first 45.

Heck, Cricket has more stoppages than the 12:35 Newcastle to Portsmouth train, so what chance have television viewers got then?

I’ve been a long advocate of getting sponsorship kicked out of the game as it would benefit the general public most, but know this will NEVER, NEVER, NEVER happen, so thought I might as well live with it as best as possible as those bloody yanks (Replace Y with W??) are just going to go ahead anyway.

Theres a reason I don’t bother myself with the World Series or The SuperBowl or the NFL,- The reason being because I’m British, the same reason I don’t bother myself with Drag Racing or NBA AllStars or the like.

After all, Yanks (Again replace Y with W??) don’t bother themselves with ‘Sar-ker’ so why should I?

The thing that gets Americans, is somebody making a boatload of money out of something and not getting a cut, because that’s just wrong isn’t it? What? Americans sit on their fannys and nail their colors to Uncle Sam’s mast?

I’d prefer to sit on my ARSE, wear my club COLOURS with pride, but due to my disregard for the queen I can’t bring myself to salute the ruler of the country.

Still, they make a great episode of Frasier, The Simpsons and E.R.

Paul

Note From Luke
Another fine rant...

Posted by: Paul Patterson  | April 28, 2008 5:55 PM

jac mills wrote...

Luke

Just thought you would like to know there ARE cricket pitches in the U.S., mainly in the East, but also some on the West Coast. Cricket is not a big sport for the Americans, and is played mainly by university teams in the areas mentioned, with some local expats forming teams, playing on Sundays and having tea afterwards. Quite civilised, I can assure you, even though I do not go out of my way to attend any of the games. But I didn't when I lived in England, and other places around the world where they play cricket, even Australia, where as you know, it is a major sport.

As for Mr. P's "fine rant" as you named it, Luke, I imagine if I showed it to my neighbours they would have a bloody good laugh. Especially the young men down at the Veteran's hospital who seem to be able to see the humourous side of most verbosity, particulary coming from the mouths of babes!

And it seems from your words that your own blood pressure may be elevated at the mention of American ownership of British sports teams(Or is it merely the nationality itself?). There's a simple solution, of course: Find someone whose nationality you approve of who is willing and able to plonk down the cash and then ban all those people you do not like. Now let's see: Chelsea, Man City, Fulham, Liverpool, Sunderland, etc. Did I miss any?

Many years ago, when I lived in the slums of Sunderland, my dear old Mum always told me to try to see the best in everything and in everyone. And I have never forgotten that. Cheers.

Note From Luke
I don't disapprove of Americans, as such, i just don't like their capitalist politicial system much. As for George W Bush, well I could be here for weeks and I haven't got time as I've a very important article write about football. My father is so disappointed, he wanted me to go into politics as well but I chose I life of riley as a sports reporter instead! Talking of politics, I'm struggling to decide who to vite for. I've always voted Labour in every single election, local and national but I don't really want to this time. However, our local Labour councillor, Jo Cassidy is very good. Tough decisions ahead me feels. Maybe I'll just close my eyes and make a cross - joke, that would make a mockery of the democratic system those Americans helped us fight for in some war or other!

Posted by: jac mills  | April 28, 2008 9:40 PM

Mike Fraser wrote...

Americans and Cricket god forbid! They can never, ever get to understand any form of cricket even if we get to 5:5 it is way too complex, far too sophisticated and far too British for them (A tautology without trying!).

I have had the unfortunate experience of taking an American to a One Day game and tried my hardest to answer a constant stream of the most banal of questions until I had to say no more questions you cannot and I will not allow you follow this game!

And that should be our answer if the billions come calling because they will ruin it and we will regret that forever.

On American sports I am convinced they were all developed with the sole reason of selling fast food.

Rain has now stopped, training is on!

Cheers

Mike

Note From Luke
An interesting comment about the food. Certainly American football and baseball allow huge quantities of food to be consumed as they are so slow moving, although basketball is the opposite. I can't see cricket ever taking off in the States - it's a struggle for them to sell football to the native population - but wherever there is money and profit to be made...

Posted by: Mike Fraser  | April 29, 2008 5:44 AM

zulu wrote...

Wow want a rant Paul- for the record I watched a few matches in the T20 World Cup in Durban, South Africa and the format is excellent. Go to the game with the family after work, have a braai (b-b-q) and a few beers. Most important thing is not to take it too seriously, as it will never take over 5-day cricket, but 50 over game looks dead in the water now. Indian Premier League is the new format, whatever the Yank money-men may think.

Note From Luke
I think the 50 over game will survive, but hopefully we'll see the back of the 40 over stuff we play in county cricket. Here's my blueprint for the future.

Start season later to allow English players to play in IPL, scrap Pro 40 league, allowing more Championship games to be played in July, August and September. Create rival Twenty20 league in June, which means we don't just let the Indians cash in on something we invented. Ultimately, I suspect, most cricketers - at least the English speaking one would prefer to play in the English tournament as it means they can also cash in by playing county cricket before and after.

Posted by: zulu  | April 29, 2008 9:09 AM

Edmond Dante wrote...

Funny Paul should mention The Simpsons above. When I heard about an American investing in County Cricket, the first person who came to mind was the crazy Texan oil tycoon who pops up from time to time in Springfield. You know, the one who says "Son, I represent a group of business man who make foolish purchases. We already got ourselves a stained glass bathroom and the worlds fattest racehorse."

Note From Luke
That's very good! Stanford is from Texas as well!

Posted by: Edmond Dante  | April 29, 2008 11:04 AM

aditya wrote...

Hey Luke,
Ive been commenting on several of your blogs in the past dedicated at Newcastle United,but this one really surprises me a lot.I hail from India and I am not too happy about your jealousy towords India exploring new dimensions of T20.You speak about the so called removal of traditional country system still for the whole blog you keep on comparing England as a country vs other countries..this in no way is global branding of sports.And you know why India has become so wealthy cricket board? Is beacause of good administration.In England I guess people have orthodox mindsets about sport.As an example when there were talks that Harry will be the new Newcastle manager..everybody was gutted.Nobody bothered to give him a chance.But in India Mr.Sharad Pawar the president of BCCI took over and people backed him,and he's changed Indian cricket like anything.Although EPL(or BPLshall i say) is the best planned administrative structre set up by English people the real poblem lies in lots of english experts waste their time speaking on television shows rather than really contributing something towords sports.

Note From Luke
Ah yes, but surely it is a compliment that I am jealous of what is happening in India. The worry, though, is that the ramifications of the IPL could ruin our own domestic game so we have to react. There is no reason why the IPL cannot continue, we just need to make sure we don't ruin our own game trying to compete with it.

Posted by: aditya  | April 29, 2008 11:27 AM

tony brown wrote...

Hello Luke,
While I agree in the main with what you say, regarding Americans and issues such as cricket,there's seldom any reason to become exercised over it because the speculation generally remains at the incipient stage for a short time before assuming its place in the Pantheon of Crap Ideas. There have been. I'll grant you, one or two that slipped past the wicket keeper and Liverpool Football club is waving from the boundary as I write, but, most of the very rich became so because they aren't entirely mad and once they sit down to examine the actual details the idea will conk out if it hasn't real merit. However, the main thrust of my note is that the late Paul Getty developed a love of cricket and, with encouragement from people including Ian Botham and Mick Jagger, embraced it in an admirable way that was very much in keeping with the spirit of the sport. People like Getty don't spring up every day, but, they do a lot to offset the damage caused by the ignorance of others. Sport nowadays depends too heavily on money and publicity, hence the involvement of unlikely luminaries such as the apparently confused Delia Smith exhorting the scant and apathetic crowd at Norwich City to sing up. Perhaps they were too polite to do so when their mouths were full of her gourmet provender, content to waddle home following another home defeat, their stomachs full and their hearts leaden. It doesn't get much better, does it? Yours, Tony Brown.

Note From Luke
More importantly Tony, what do you make of Delia's new show? Do you agree with her attempt to prove you can cook good food with frozen and ready-made ingredients? Of has the sherry drinking, Norwich City motivational speaker lost the plot?

Posted by: tony brown  | April 29, 2008 1:35 PM

jac mills wrote...

Luke, You Old Devil

It would seem you started a real fire storm with your comments on cricket and India and America. Just what you wanted anyway, wasn't it? No flies on you, mate. And if it means anything, I would bet big money that cricket never would take hold in the U.S. So rest easy! But keep the jibes coming. They seem to work for you.

Posted by: jac mills  | April 29, 2008 5:13 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)