Grab my RSS feed | (What's this?)

About this Blog

Luke Edwards is Chief Sports Writer of The Journal and uses his blog to give a unique and entertaining insight into events at Newcastle United and Sunderland.

As well as football, Luke also regularly takes a wry look at the biggest sports stories from across the North-East and beyond. From cricket to rugby and basketball to boxing, some are criticised and some are praised.

Sometimes provocative, sometimes laugh-aloud funny, but always interesting Luke Who's Talking also gives you the chance to interact with Luke and have your say on all the major sporting issues.

Recent comments

Recent Posts

Sponsored links

Archives

Links

Sponsored links


Worries On Wearside

Posted by Luke on July 15, 2008 6:26 PM | 

It is still a little too soon for the alarm bells to start ringing or for panic buttons to be frantically pressed by fans still trying to pay for their season tickets, but I'm starting to worry about Sunderland ahead of the new season.

Having just about avoided yet another immediate return to the Championship last season, Roy Keane spoke confidently of developing the club over the summer, trimming the dead or dying wood from his squad and investing in players who would be able to take the team on to the next level - in other words keep them clear of the bottom three and, possibly, just possibly, give them an outside chance of a top eight finish.

It was always a bold plan in keeping with their young and ambitious manager, but it looks like a ludicrous one at the moment as Sunderland supporters continue to wait for news of the first new signing.

With more than six weeks of the transfer window remaining there is still enough time to recruit the five or six players needed to improve the squad sufficiently, but it is starting to look unlikely they will arrive in time and that does not bode well.

As things stand, Sunderland are a hardworking, dedicated side with a manager who has managed to consistently get the best out of the players at his disposal, but will that be enough for a second season in the top flight?

It wasn't for Reading after they failed to make the necessary additions to their squad 12 months ago following an encouraging first season in the Premier League! Reading will not be missed - nothing club from a nothing town near London - but Sunderland should be wary of treading a similar path.

Sunderland desperately need two new centre backs, a left-back, two creative midfielders and a striker. Some would argue they need even more than that, but the market is proving to be a tough place for the Black Cats to operate and frustration is gradually growing on Wearside.

They are not the only ones, of course, but Keane must be starting to get a little concerned about the lack of progress being made. The likes of Darren Bent, Jonny Evans and Andy Johnson would all be good additions to the side, but none of them look as though they will be wearing the red and white stripes next season, preferring to either stay where they are or move to another Premier League club.

As ever, Sunderland have been linked with a ridiculous number of players, both at home and abroad, in the last few weeks - and not all of them are Irish or have played for Manchester United - but it is time for the speculation to start turning into something a little more concrete.

If new signings do not come in sufficient numbers the Black Cats will be involved in another relegation battle and without the momentum which was with them at the start of last season following promotion, they are vulnerable.

The other worry is that, as the close of the window approaches, the danger is that players will be signed for the sake of it. No matter how hard a manager tries to avoid this particular pitfall, he knows the supporters and the players are anticipating new arrivals and sometimes the temptation is to sign someone you hope can do a job for you, rather than someone you know will.

Keane has some previous here as well. Rade Prica, for example, cost £2.5m in January but has still not started a game for the club. Other summer signings like Russell Anderson and Greg Halford have also been notable failures and, for all of the money spent in his two years at the Stadium of Light, the jury is out on his judgement in the transfer market.

On a brighter note, Keane's most successful signing last year was Kenwyne Jones and he didn't arrive on Wearside until the final week before the window closed having started the season with former club Southampton. A handful of signings of his calibre in the coming weeks and we'll be wondering what all the fuss was about!

Comments (8)

Dale wrote...

Rada Prica?? I hope Roy Keane hasn't been paying Championship Manager 01/02??!!

Things may be grim on Tyneside but not half as grim as it is on Wearside.

Posted by: Dale  | July 16, 2008 8:57 AM

Henrya wrote...

Maybe I'm mellowing in my old age but as a lifelong Black and White I find it a little troubling that Sunderland may struggle this season. Our derby games are the only passionate games we had last season and I'm sure that it'll be much of the same this coming term too. Don't get me wrong mind, I hate them with the same passion that have for hating us but there is a great "respect" for simply being passionate and turning up no matter what. I hope that Roy Keane does enough to bring new players to the club and that they stay in the Premiership albeit a few places beneath us. Wouldn't you think that a move down the A19 might be a good one for both sides if they were to take Shola? I would imagine that him and Jones could do some damage as a partnership.
Anyway, let's all look forward to the season and hope that both clubs do enough to generate excitement and pleasuren and we finish higher than them!

Posted by: Henrya  | July 16, 2008 9:16 AM

ron lambert wrote...

Oh dear.....oh my....oh well. sincerely, Busker

Posted by: ron lambert  | July 16, 2008 12:41 PM

JC wrote...

I predict another season of torture for the Sunderland masses. Realistically the players they have been linked with would all view Sunderland as a risk, the fact remains that they are a perennial yo-yo team, who will be amongst the favourites to go down next year. I'm sure Roy Keane will sign some ex Ireland colleague or a Man U or Celtic fringe man, but this will not be enough to avoid relegation. Sunderlands problem is that they think one season of staying up will be enough to convince 'big names' to sign. Realistically they'll be looking for the scraps that noone really wants.....By the way Sunderland fans, Ameobi's still for sale!

Posted by: JC  | July 16, 2008 12:59 PM

Ben K wrote...

Reading will not be missed? They played free flowing football and got in a few shoot-outs last year. It's always nice to have a couple of defenseless sides in the league that you can hit up for a few goals. How I would have rather seen Wigan or Bolton go down, if not just to send their stadiums to the championship where they belong.

I guess I sort of fell for Reading and their suprise season two years ago in a league of no suprises. They almost qualified for Europe! I think the second tier of clubs (Villa, Pompey, Citeh, Rovers) has improved greatly over the last couple of years and a promoted team 'pulling a Reading' again soon is unlikely. They haven't been selling this summer and profited greatly (financially) from a couple of Premiership seasons, so maybe they'll bounce right back. I for one would love to see it.

Oh, and Mackems are going down, no doubt about it.

Posted by: Ben K  | July 16, 2008 2:53 PM

Mike Ashburn wrote...

You pays your money and you takes your chance,as the old saying goes.
But,if you don't pay ANY money........!?

Posted by: Mike Ashburn  | July 16, 2008 4:42 PM

Sy wrote...

I just opened this post expecting a bunch of responses by Mackems saying things like "it's about time there was a story about us!" and such like, as well as commenting on Luke's article - whether they be the deluded kind or the realistic kind. But no, seems to be mostly Geordies!

Not one to buck a trend, I'll continue...

I agree with JC's comments about unrealistic expectations - even though it's supposed to be the Newcastle fans who are unrealistic!

Some of the players they've been linked with are complete pie in the sky. If they could persuade Malbranque to go there I think that'd be a valuable signing for them.

Newcastle's problem has been a change of transfer attitude instigated by Ashley which has possibly caused delays or changing of targets. Sunderland though don't seem to have this, with Quinn seemingly happy to support Keane in the transfer market. You never know what happens behind closed doors, but one can only suspect that there's a lack of interest in Sunderland from Keane's targetted players. Darren Bent springs to mind...if this link was true.

I'd also agree that unless they get some quality in (by which I mean quality and not necessarily high-profile), they may be in for a big struggle next season...Just look at Hull's recruitment drive so far which has left others standing.

Oh, final point...Couldn't agree more with Ben K where he said he'd rather have seen Bolton go down as opposed to Reading. The sooner Bolton are out of this league the better it will be for football. (Feel free to prove me wrong next season, Bolton...but I doubt you will.)

Posted by: Sy  | July 16, 2008 8:00 PM

Carrot wrote...

Finally a story that isn't about NUFC! (had to get that in apparently)

I am not troubled in anyway by the lack of signings so far - it's not as if everyone is making loads anyway (besides Hull). It also shows that Keane isn't going about this the same way he did last year - where there were difinate signings for the sake of it. I think Keane and Quinn have the trust of all the SAFC fans, so maybe thats why we aren't too bothered about signings right now. Keane knows what is needed, and I believe he is doing what is needed to try and make signings happen.

I agree that some of the names linked with us are ridiculous, but every year yeams are linked with players who will never ever sign - look at Citeh and Ronaldiniho!

I think for the first time in a long time, for two seasons in a row I am confident that we will be safe from relegation, and for now that will do me - don't want to have any dillusions of grandure (eh NUFC?)

Note From Luke
So what do you make of the quadruple swoop for half of Tottenham's Reserve team? I'm not convinced all of them will sign, but even if they just get two - say Malbranque and Chimbonda - Keane will have done well.

Posted by: Carrot  | July 17, 2008 12:25 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)